Choosing the right all-in-one printer can feel overwhelming. You need something reliable, efficient, and fits your budget. This is exactly the dilemma many face when comparing the Canon Pixma TR4720 and the Brother MFC-J1010DW. This post will help you decide which printer best suits your needs by providing a comprehensive comparison of their features, performance, and overall value. We’ll cover everything you need to know to make an informed decision.
Print Quality and Speed
This section compares the print quality and printing speeds of both the Canon Pixma TR4720 and Brother MFC-J1010DW. We’ll examine the resolution, print speeds for different document types, and overall print quality.
Canon Pixma TR4720 Print Quality
- Print Resolution: The Canon Pixma TR4720 boasts a maximum print resolution of 4800 x 1200 dpi, resulting in sharp and detailed prints. This high resolution is ideal for documents and photos requiring high levels of clarity. Many users find that even photos look crisp and clean with this printer, exceeding expectations in its price range.
- Print Speed: The print speed for black and white documents is generally faster than color prints. Typical speeds are around 8.0ipm for black and 4.0ipm for color. However, these speeds can vary depending on the complexity of the document and print settings selected. For large print jobs, it’s important to keep expectations aligned with these benchmarks.
Brother MFC-J1010DW Print Quality
- Print Resolution: The Brother MFC-J1010DW offers a maximum print resolution of 6000 x 1200 dpi. This means that theoretically, the Brother could produce even finer details compared to the Canon. However, this resolution depends on specific settings. The real-world difference between the two printers may not be dramatically noticeable.
- Print Speed: Similar to the Canon, the Brother MFC-J1010DW demonstrates faster black and white printing (up to 20ipm) than color printing (around 10ipm). The advertised speeds are noticeably quicker than the Canon, though users may observe some variation depending on print job complexity and paper type.
Connectivity and Features
Here, we’ll explore the connectivity options and additional features offered by each printer, including wireless capabilities, mobile printing options, and any special functionalities.
Wireless Connectivity
- Canon Pixma TR4720: The Canon Pixma TR4720 offers wireless connectivity through Wi-Fi, enabling easy printing from laptops, smartphones, and tablets. This setup usually requires downloading a Canon app for simpler mobile printing.
- Brother MFC-J1010DW: The Brother MFC-J1010DW also supports wireless printing via Wi-Fi, providing similar convenience. It is also compatible with various wireless printing protocols, enabling compatibility with diverse mobile devices and operating systems.
Additional Features
- Canon Pixma TR4720: This printer comes with features such as automatic duplex printing and borderless printing. The automatic duplex printing saves paper costs, while borderless printing allows for creating attractive photos without white borders.
- Brother MFC-J1010DW: The Brother MFC-J1010DW is an all-in-one device, including a scanner and copier. The addition of a copier and scanner is significant, adding functionality not available on the Canon Pixma TR4720. This versatility might be a key factor for many users.
Cost and Running Costs
This section delves into the initial purchase price of each printer and compares their ongoing running costs, considering ink cartridge prices and overall efficiency.
Initial Purchase Price
The initial cost of the Canon Pixma TR4720 is generally lower than the Brother MFC-J1010DW. This price difference is partly due to the additional features offered by the Brother, namely the inclusion of a scanner and copier.
Running Costs
Running costs can vary significantly depending on usage. It’s crucial to consider ink cartridge costs per page. Generally, both printers use relatively inexpensive ink cartridges, although direct comparison requires checking the current market prices of the individual cartridges. Insert a comparison chart here showing ink cartridge prices and page yields for both printers.
| Feature | Canon Pixma TR4720 | Brother MFC-J1010DW |
|---|---|---|
| Initial Price (USD) | ~ $80 | ~ $120 |
| Black Ink Cartridge Cost (USD) | ~ $15 | ~ $12 |
| Color Ink Cartridge Cost (USD) | ~ $18 | ~ $15 |
Ease of Use and Setup
Here, we’ll discuss the user-friendliness of both printers, focusing on their setup process, software, and overall ease of operation. User reviews often highlight the setup experience, so this is crucial for comparison.
Setup Process
- Canon Pixma TR4720: The Canon Pixma TR4720 generally has a straightforward setup process. Most users find it easy to install the printer drivers and connect it to a wireless network. The printer’s accompanying app simplifies this process for mobile users.
- Brother MFC-J1010DW: The Brother MFC-J1010DW, while also relatively easy to set up, might involve slightly more steps due to the additional scanner and copier functionalities. However, the software provided is usually well-designed and guides users effectively through the process.
Software and Driver Support
Both Canon and Brother provide comprehensive driver support for various operating systems. Their websites offer readily available software for download and troubleshooting guides, ensuring compatibility and support across different platforms.
Mythbusting: Ink Cartridge Myths
Myth 1: Refilling Ink Cartridges Always Saves Money
While refilling cartridges can seem appealing, the cost savings aren’t always guaranteed. Low-quality refills can damage the printer, negating any savings. It is essential to use high-quality refill inks.
Myth 2: Generic Cartridges are as Good as OEM
Using generic ink cartridges can lead to inconsistencies in print quality and may even damage your printer. While they might be cheaper initially, the long-term cost can outweigh the savings.
Canon Pixma TR4720 vs Brother MFC-J1010DW: A Summary
The best choice between the Canon Pixma TR4720 and the Brother MFC-J1010DW depends heavily on your specific needs and priorities. The Canon is simpler and more affordable, while the Brother offers more functionalities. If scanning and copying are essential, the Brother is superior. Consider your budget, usage patterns, and desired features before making a decision.
FAQ
What is the difference in paper handling capabilities?
The Canon Pixma TR4720 and Brother MFC-J1010DW both handle standard paper sizes. However, check specific specifications for details on maximum paper capacity and supported paper types.
Which printer is better for photo printing?
While both printers can handle photo printing, the Canon Pixma TR4720 might be slightly better suited for high-quality photo prints due to its slightly higher maximum print resolution. However, the difference is small in practice.
How easy is it to maintain both printers?
Maintenance is minimal for both. Regular ink cartridge replacements and occasional cleaning are the main requirements.
Do both printers have mobile printing capabilities?
Yes, both printers offer mobile printing capabilities via Wi-Fi and their respective apps.
Which printer is more energy-efficient?
The energy consumption varies depending on usage; checking the manufacturer specifications is best for precise information.
What is the warranty offered for each printer?
Refer to the manufacturer’s website or documentation for warranty details as these can change.
Are there any user reviews I can check before purchasing?
Yes, many online retailers and review sites offer user reviews of both printers. It is highly recommended to check these reviews before making a purchase decision.
Final Thoughts
Choosing between the Canon Pixma TR4720 and Brother MFC-J1010DW involves weighing several factors. Carefully consider your printing needs, budget, and desired features. Reading user reviews and comparing current prices can significantly aid your decision-making process. Ultimately, the best printer is the one that best fits your specific requirements. Don’t hesitate to research further based on your personal priorities!
